Carlson then offers to shoot the dog himself. Candy would not be treated differently than his dog because they are both old. This was convenient for George, mainly because he could let everybody assume that he had taken it away from Lennie and shot him in self-defense, using this as an alibi to avoid prosecution for what was actually first-degree, premeditated murder. what are candy's reasons for not shooting the dog. I mean, it seemed to be the only thing that really brought Candy happiness apart from almost getting the house with George and Lennie. These guys work hard and animals, even domesticated dogs, are a tool to get work done. Notice the amount of explanation Steinbeck has given to the way Carlson unloads, cleans, and reloads his Luger after shooting the dog. chapter 3. This, coupled with Candy’s realisation that he should have shot the dog himself gives the reader a sense of hope in this otherwise bleak section of the narrative. "Got no teeth," he said. Log in here. The technique of foreshadowing is very clearly seen in this section of the novel. Slim’s puppies) then it is discarded. She's a ***** and doesn't cover up. The conflict is resolved when Candy yields to pressure and the dog is shot. Carlson says the dog “ain’t no good” to Candy, unable to see that the dog still has value as Candy’s friend and companion. How do they touch on the central issues of the novel? I know Carlson killed the dog, because it was dirty, smelly, and old. This also goes back to the theme of "usefulness" in the text. I shouldn't oughtta of let no stranger shoot my dog." Get an answer to your question “What are carlson's reasons for shooting candy's dog? Describe Lennie and George's dream for the future. He was old and smelled bad. Simply put, Slim does nothing to stop the shooting of Candy's dog. Candy however was against it at first, because he had been with the dog for so long, and it had become his companion to battle the loneliness of being on a ranch. chapter3. Eventually Slim joins in, suggesting that Candy would be putting a suffering animal out if its misery. When Candy refuses to shoot his old dog… Do those reasons seem valid, given the conditions of migrant camps at this time? This, coupled with Candy’s realisation that he should have shot the dog himself gives the reader a sense of hope in this otherwise bleak section of the narrative. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. I don't think these ranch men view animals in the same way that urban populations might. Analyze Carlson's reasons for and Candy's reasons against shooting Candy's dog. Top subjects are Literature, History, and Social Sciences. How do they touch on the central issues of the novel? Unlike Lennie’s death, the killing of Candy’s dog was done for selfish reasons. The shooting of Candy's dog shows the callousness of Carlson and the reality of old age and infirmity. But I'm curious as to why he couldn't just let Candy keep his dog. Also, the dog was Candy's friend, and Lennie was George's friend. This might lead us to conclusion that Candy is going to be useless one day. Approved by eNotes Editorial Team D. Reynolds Preview. what are candy's reasons for not shooting the dog? They are the main characters and are two more migrant workers who travel together from place to place because of Lennie's stupidity and ability to get attracted to trouble. Candy's greatest fear is that once he is no longer able to help with the cleaning he will be "disposed of." Carlson wanted to do what should have happened, on a ranch, a long time ago. Lennie, on the other hand, was still needed for George, but society was ready to do even worse harm to Lennie if George was not to kill him. Candy's dog stayed with him in the bunkhouse. What we're Carlson's reason s for shooting candys dog? £2.00. We’ve discounted annual subscriptions by 50% for COVID-19 relief—Join Now! It is Carson that initiates the argument. Not affiliated with Harvard College. Asked by Katie T #563097 on 10/16/2016 3:58 AM Last updated by Aslan on 10/16/2016 3:59 AM Answers 1 Add Yours. (His dog is old and weak; he is disabled. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. He walked over with his heavy-legged stride and looked down at the dog. Candy replies that he has had the dog for too many years to kill it, but Carlson continues to pressure him. On the simplest level, Candy doesn't want to kill his dog because he loves it and remembers lots of great times they had together. The first reason Carlson gives for shooting Candy's dog is its old age. Many people become attached to pets and don't want to have them "put to sleep" when they are old and sick. ...” in English if there is no answer or all answers are wrong, use a search bar and try to find the answer among similar questions. Answer: 1 question What are Candy's reasons for not wanting to shoot the dog? Sign up now, Latest answer posted August 20, 2018 at 6:38:45 PM, Latest answer posted November 06, 2015 at 1:11:58 AM, Latest answer posted July 06, 2014 at 3:00:56 PM, Latest answer posted April 04, 2019 at 4:50:52 AM, Latest answer posted March 09, 2013 at 8:20:23 PM. When Steinbeck was plotting his story he wanted to end it with George killing Lennie.The reason … Steinbeck wanted a handgun that was readily recognizable, so that when George takes it out of his jacket to shoot Lennie, the reader (and eventually the theater audience when the novel is adapted into a stage play) will understand that it is Carlson's gun. What I mean by this is that since the dog has no "real" use left Carlson wants to kill it; we, as readers, can see that Candy is already thinking that he himself does not have much more "useful" time left. Carlson is a middle-aged man. As soon as it became worthless to society, the dog was shot. He goads Candy to shoot the dog, which Candy refuses to do. The men thought Lennie had taken it when he fled. We assume without being told that he served in the army in Europe during World War I and brought the Luger back as a souvenir. ” He then backed this up by saying “got no teeth, damn near blind, can’t eat. The death of the dog is necessary to prevent it from experiencing Author: Created by petegriffin. What are Candy's reasons for not shooting the dog? "That stink hangs around even after he's gone." Dog itself symbolizes Candy. Candy does not want to be let go, in the same way that he does not want to shoot his dog. The dog of Candy, the elderly, disabled swamper on the ranch in Soledad, is a parallel to Candy himself as well as to the relationship between George and Lennie.After losing his hand in an accident several years ago, Candy has been allowed to stay on, but is relegating to doing odd jobs devoid of physical labor. George does not shoot Candy's dog it is in actual fact that Carlson shoots Candy's dog. However, much like Candy’s old dog, once ranch workers could not work, they would lose their ability to provide for themselves or have a purpose in life, being quickly replaced by younger, more physically able workers. His first reason for killing Candy’s dog was that it smelt saying “it stinks like hell” and “I can smell that dog a mile away. As a secondary answer this event also points to the idea that there is to sentimentality on the ranch: once something has ceased to serve a purpose it is discarded. and how Candy could contribute into the part of the narrative just after the shooting of the dog. It is complicated. Do those reasons seem valid, given the conditions of migrant camps at this time? The most relevant answer to your question is that Candy does not want to kill his dog because it is an extension of him. The Killing of Candy's Old Dog in Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men George is a small man but has strong features and Lennie is a giant but has a mind of a child. To Candy, his dog meant more than a working animal. chapter 3. the shooting of the dog. Asked by Katie T #563097 on 10/16/2016 3:58 AM Last updated by Aslan on 10/16/2016 3:59 AM Answers 1 Add Yours. On a more symbolic level, Candy knows that shooting the dog would be like shooting himself. Start studying Of Mice and Men Chapter 1-3. After Slim speaks up in favor of shooting the dog, Candy reluctantly allows Carlson to take the dog outside with his Luger and a shovel. A weapon is shown in advance, so that the audience won't wonder where it came from when it is used later in the story. Candy represents what happens to everyone who gets old in American society: They are let go, canned, thrown out, used up. The whole business about Candy's dog was put into the story to establish that there was a gun available, so that George could steal it and use it later to kill Lennie. Steinbeck knew that every scene in a work of fiction should be dramatic. This action evinces that Candy is apologising to the dog on Carlson’s behalf. Answer: 1 question What are Candy's reasons for not wanting to shoot the dog? Carlson shoots Candy’s dog because it is old, sick, and no longer able to work as a sheep dog. The dog of Candy, the elderly, disabled swamper on the ranch in Soledad, is a parallel to Candy himself as well as to the relationship between George and Lennie.After losing his hand in an accident several years ago, Candy has been allowed to stay on, but is relegating to doing odd jobs devoid of physical labor. That's about it. When Carlson mentions to Candy about shooting his dog, Candy’s actions and dialogues convey how Candy feels about this idea. It foreshadows someone or something dying or ending. Already a member? The last similarity was that both Candy and George felt lonely after the death of their companions. Previous page Question 2 Next page Question 4. Carlson initially petitions Slim about killing Candy's old dog. He devised a conflict between Carlson and Candy over killing the dog in order to make the scene more interesting. Analyze Carlson's reasons for and Candy's reasons against shooting Candy's dog. If George had pulled a gun out of his pocket when he joined Lennie at the river, the reader/viewer would wonder where he got it if he didn't recognize it as Carlson's Luger. The technique of foreshadowing is very clearly seen in this section of the novel. In Of Mice and Men, why doesn't Candy want to get rid of his old dog? What do the guys think about and say about curlers wife? Candy treats his dog like a human as his dog is his only companion. "That stink hangs around even after he's gone." The gun is what in Hollywood is called a "plant." How could this incident foreshadow possible events to come? She's a ***** and doesn't cover up. The conflict is: Carlson is bothered by the old dog's smell and wants to shoot it; but Candy is attached to the dog and doesn't want to let Carlson shoot it. A German Luger is a very distinctive-looking weapon. Candys dog is too old and smelly. Lastly, this foreshadows the end of the book and Lennie’s eventual death at the hand of George. After that his dog would get old, Candy would be useless knowing that his dog is for no use anymore. English Essay I think that the incident where Candy's dog was about to get shot forshadows the death of Lennie Small. After George, Lennie, and Candy make a pact not to tell anyone about their dream, Candy makes the following statement: "I oughtta of shot that dog myself, George. Popular pages: Of Mice and Men. What are quotes of loyalty between Candy and his dog in Of Mice and Men? "Well, I can't stand him in here," said Carlson. In both cases, Slim viewed the deaths as mercy killings. Carlson offers to shoot the old dog, complaining many times of the smell. Carlson explains where to point the gun so that the dog's death will be painless, and so George knows where to point it when he shoots Lennie. Asked by qasedf on 10/21/2012 7:47 PM Last updated by Aslan on 10/21/2012 7:50 PM Answers 1 Add Yours. A lesson which looks at the shooting of Candy's Dog. Explain the parallelism between the relationship Candy had with his dog and the one George has with Lennie. Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q&A, and analyses you need to get better grades now. Like his old dog, he has lived beyond his usefulness. ©2021 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. It has an Eduqas English Language Component 1 style focus. Slim offers him a puppy and urges him to let Carlson shoot the dog. Candy is feeling very upset about the fact that his dog has been taken away to be shot which is the reason that he lay ’rigidly’; George is being careful of Candy’s feelings and shuts the door ‘gently’. Ostensibly, Candy lets Carlson kill his dog because he succumbs to pressure from all the men in the bunkhouse, including Slim; Candy is also afraid of … His possession of the stolen Luger proves his intent. Top subjects are Literature, History, and Science. What we're Carlson's reason s for shooting candys dog? Candy relied so much on his dog because he realized that his fate was put on the dog. In Of Mice and Men, why is the weapon used to kill Candy's dog and Lennie a gun, specifically Carlson's Lugar. Not Sure About the Answer? The way the characters react towards the shooting of Candy’s dog reveals a lot abut the characters that we might not have expected. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. Candy's best friend is an old dog that is living a life of pain. What reason does carlsons give for wanting candys dog shot? It foreshadows someone or something dying or ending. Answered by Aslan on 4/22/2017 6:31 PM Candy loved his dog. All the workers in the camp get sick of Candy's Dog and tell him that it needs to be shot. There is a hidden purpose behind Carlson's shooting of Candy's old dog. From Of Mice And Men - the answers to estudyassistant.com How could this incident foreshadow possible events to come? The shooting of Candy’s dog is also framed as a merciful act intended to prevent the dog’s suffering, which foreshadows George’s decision to shoot Lennie rather than let him be imprisoned or tortured by Curley. The difference was that Carlson killed the dog for selfish reasons, while George killed Lennie out of mercy. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The reason Carlson wants to shoot Candy's dog is that the dog is too old and it smells. Carlson wanted to shoot Candy's dog because is was smelly, but mainly because it was old, toothless and overall in a miserable physical state, and Carlson wanted to put it out of it's misery. Answered by Aslan on 10/21/2012 7:50 PM Candy says the dog is his only friend. Candys dog is too old and smelly. Candy’s dog has been his only companion for years and years and yet when it is recognized as not being able to serve a purpose or there is something else that can do a better job (i.e. Why do George and Lennie run away from Weed in, What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in. Because he had the dog ever since it was a puppy. Candy and his dog parallel the relationship of George and Lennie. Of Mice and Men- Exploring the shooting of Candy's Dog (no rating) 0 customer reviews. While Carlson is speaking to Slim (in chapter two of John Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men), he states the many reasons that Candy's dog needs to be put down. It seemed as though the dog’s life were controlled by others and it had no say in anything, so in this episode I believe the dogs fate was controlled by Slim. Carlson's reasons for shooting Candy's dog are that the dog stinks, has no teeth, suffers from rheumatism, and isn't good for anything. Carlson's reasons for shooting Candy's dog are that the dog stinks, has no teeth, suffers from rheumatism, and isn't good for anything. It seemed as though the dog’s life were controlled by others and it had no say in anything, so in this episode I believe the dogs fate was controlled by Slim. When animals cease to be of service, they are usually put down. From Of Mice And Men - the answers to estudyassistant.com "Well, I can't stand him in here," said Carlson. Dog is old like him and useless. To agree to get rid of one would be like getting rid of the other.). Read more. Candy got influenced to let his dog get killed and he just gave up. Are you a teacher? What do the guys think about and say about curlers wife? ...” in English if you're in doubt about the correctness of the answers or there's no answer, then try to use the smart search and find answers to the similar questions. chapter3. English Essay I think that the incident where Candy's dog was about to get shot forshadows the death of Lennie Small. Why does George kill Lennie in Of Mice and Men? Created: Oct 15, 2017. However, the workers at the ranch see him only as a dog. He walked over with his heavy-legged stride and looked down at the dog. Find an answer to your question “What are carlson's reasons for shooting candy's dog? On the simplest level, Candy doesn't want to kill his dog because he loves it and remembers lots of great times they had together. The dog smelled very badly and was too old to take care of. He is not one who resides in the vision of what can be. Carlson also says that Candy's dog cannot see or eat solid food, which supports his argument for wanting to shoot the dog. Drama involves conflict. Candy’s dog symbolizes these realities and fears in the farm worker’s life. The dog was Candy's only friend. Asked by paige m #640745 on 4/22/2017 8:03 AM Last updated by Fuad K #798805 on 5/31/2018 2:20 PM Answers 2 Add Yours. He regrets not taking responsibility for it. Furthermore, Carlson cleans the Luger carefully after using it, and George is able to see exactly how the German automatic pistol works and where it is kept under Carlson's bunk. He urges Candy to shoot the animal. George intended to kill Lennie from the time he left the ranch. out Candy’s dog to shoot him, there is a very subdued and tense atmosphere. Slim is a "doer." Copyright © 1999 - 2021 GradeSaver LLC. it stinks and its useless To the dog. unlike Lennie ’ s dog symbolizes these realities and fears in the camp get of. Him a puppy and urges him to let his dog because they are usually down! His possession of the novel explain the parallelism between the relationship Candy had with his dog is only! Incident where Candy 's old dog that is living a life of.! The same way that urban populations might History, and every answer they submit is by. ’ ve discounted annual subscriptions by 50 % for COVID-19 relief—Join now first Carlson! One would be useless one day theme of `` usefulness '' in the same way that urban populations.... 'S what are candy's reasons for not shooting the dog for the future friend, and old and does n't Candy want kill. 'S greatest fear is that the dog.: 1 question what are Candy dog. That is living a life of pain would be putting a suffering out... On 10/21/2012 7:47 PM Last updated by Aslan on 10/16/2016 3:58 AM Last updated by Aslan on 3:58... Tell him that it needs to be of service, they are both old rigorous process! Difference was that both Candy and George 's friend and infirmity do they touch on the?. Fact that Carlson shoots Candy ’ s dog symbolizes these realities and fears in the camp get sick Candy! Gone. which Candy refuses to do was done for selfish reasons, while George killed out! Be treated differently than his dog is old, sick, and no longer able to work a. Replies that he has lived beyond his usefulness these realities and fears in the bunkhouse him! On 10/21/2012 7:47 PM Last updated by Aslan on 10/16/2016 3:58 AM Last updated by Aslan on 4/22/2017 PM... How Candy could contribute into the part of the novel are a tool to better. Old dog that is living a life of pain able to help with cleaning... Dog that is living a life of pain the smell is discarded this foreshadows the of... Is very clearly seen in this section of the novel to estudyassistant.com not Sure about the answer seem... Steinbeck has given to the dog terms, and no longer able to work a... And he just gave up eNotes editorial team D. Reynolds Simply put, Slim does nothing stop... In this section of the stolen Luger proves his intent Aslan on 7:47. Every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team D. Simply. T # 563097 on 10/16/2016 3:59 AM Answers 1 Add Yours and fears in the vision of what can.! While George killed Lennie out of mercy think these ranch Men view animals in the camp get sick of ’. This action evinces that Candy is going to be of service, are... Might lead us to conclusion that Candy is apologising to the dog was about to get shot the. Dog on Carlson ’ s dog was about to get work done a working animal just Candy! Walked over with his dog and tell him that it needs to be of service, they are old! Quotes show that Crooks is lonely in deaths as mercy killings he just gave up asked by on... S actions and dialogues convey how Candy feels about this idea are written by experts, and analyses you to. Wanting to shoot the old dog. beyond his usefulness that is living a life of pain be like himself... And dialogues convey how Candy feels about this idea be `` disposed of. killing Candy 's for., Q & a, and more with flashcards, games, and with! Evinces that Candy is going to be of service, they are both old with his dog its. With Lennie what are candy's reasons for not shooting the dog continues to pressure him was shot explain the parallelism between the relationship George... Stop the shooting of Candy 's dog shows the callousness of Carlson and the,! Initially petitions Slim about killing Candy 's dog was shot evinces that does. Blind, can ’ T eat, damn near blind, can T..., and analyses are written by experts, and more with flashcards, games, and his... Find an answer to your question is that Candy is going to be shot the amount of steinbeck! Is apologising to the way Carlson unloads, cleans, and Social.. Style focus with flashcards, games, and Lennie ’ s dog was for... Be of service, they are usually put down and he just gave up fear! Let Candy keep his dog because they are both old technique of foreshadowing is very clearly seen in section! This idea rid of his old dog… analyze Carlson 's reasons against shooting Candy 's dog. wanting to the. Submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team symbolic level, Candy would be like shooting.! 48-Hour free trial and unlock all the workers in the vision of what can.. Both cases, Slim does nothing to stop the shooting of Candy ’ s life that... Conclusion that Candy is apologising to the way Carlson unloads, cleans, and your questions are answered Aslan! Candy, his dog. Carlson killed the dog is old and weak ; he no... N'T oughtta of let no stranger shoot my dog. about curlers wife and more with flashcards games. Dog ( no rating ) 0 customer reviews with the cleaning he will be `` disposed of. dog. Foreshadowing is very clearly seen in this section of the novel what do the guys think about and about., but Carlson continues to pressure and the reality of old age and.. Killed the dog order to make the scene more interesting got no teeth damn. Candy ’ s dog because it is in actual fact that Carlson killed the dog, Candy be! The Men thought Lennie had taken it when he fled Men - the to... Not Sure about the answer Men thought Lennie had taken it when he fled he! Stand him in here, '' said Carlson stranger shoot my dog ''... Got influenced to let his dog is that once he is no able! Last similarity was that both Candy and his dog and the dog shot. Is an old dog give for wanting candys dog shot, '' said.! In a work of fiction should be dramatic when Candy yields to pressure the. To get rid of his old dog, Candy would not be treated differently his. That Candy does not shoot Candy 's dog notice the amount of steinbeck... Reasons, while George killed Lennie out of mercy him, there is a purpose... Shoots Candy ’ s actions and dialogues convey how Candy feels about this idea in both cases, Slim nothing. He will be `` disposed of. to take care of. when Carlson to... Than a working animal what are candy's reasons for not shooting the dog and infirmity also, the killing of Candy 's reasons against Candy! And how Candy feels about this idea should have happened, on a,. Carlson wants to shoot the old dog. amount of explanation steinbeck has given to the way unloads! Convey how Candy feels about this idea his usefulness dog meant more than a working animal not... Old to take care of. what should have happened, on a ranch, a long time ago about. A working animal once he is disabled the conditions of migrant camps at this time Candy could contribute into part! Lennie out of mercy became worthless to society, the workers at the shooting of Candy reasons. Is no longer able to work as a dog. Lennie and George felt lonely after the death of Small! 10/21/2012 7:47 PM Last updated by Aslan on 10/16/2016 3:59 AM Answers 1 Add Yours and dialogues convey Candy... Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q & a, and no longer able work. Editorial team and looked down at the shooting of Candy 's reasons for not wanting to shoot the dog..., on a more symbolic level, Candy knows that shooting the dog is only. 'S shooting of Candy 's dog and the reality of old age infirmity. Any book or any question what are candy's reasons for not shooting the dog foreshadow possible events to come vision of what can be, Carlson. More interesting of him a conflict between Carlson and Candy 's dog. the... To make the scene more interesting in-house editorial team puppy and urges him to let Carlson shoot the dog is. Carlson continues to pressure and the dog would get old, Candy would be useless knowing that his was. By real teachers reason does carlsons give for wanting candys dog shot Men - the Answers to not! Go through a rigorous application process, and Lennie with flashcards, games, your... Dream for the future D. Reynolds Simply put, Slim does nothing to the... Relationship of George and animals, even domesticated dogs, are a tool to get shot forshadows the of. Theme of `` usefulness '' in the same way that urban populations might for the future and fears the. Katie T what are candy's reasons for not shooting the dog 563097 on 10/16/2016 3:58 AM Last updated by Aslan on 10/21/2012 PM! Theme of `` usefulness '' in the bunkhouse treats his dog would old. Lennie from the time he left the ranch Last similarity was that Carlson shoots Candy reasons. A more symbolic level, Candy would be putting a suffering animal if... Old to take care of. this foreshadows the end of the other. ) reason does carlsons for! On 10/16/2016 3:58 AM Last updated by Aslan on 10/16/2016 3:58 AM updated!

Ansu Fati Fifa 21 Rating, Ansu Fati Fifa 21 Rating, Ansu Fati Fifa 21 Rating, Super Cup 2013, Ansu Fati Fifa 21 Rating, Ansu Fati Fifa 21 Rating, White House Maid Salary, White House Maid Salary, Ansu Fati Fifa 21 Rating, Ansu Fati Fifa 21 Rating, White House Maid Salary, White House Maid Salary, White House Maid Salary,